No, you’re not really a dummy. We just needed a catchy title! We actually discuss index benchmark performance with our clients all the time. Despite the problems of using indexes as a measure of investment portfolio success, the feedback from clients is often the same: “But how did we compare to the S&P 500, NASDAQ, Dow Jones, etc.?”.
So, while we cater to client demand to show index benchmarks, we also disclose the numerous problems with it:
Diversification: If your portfolio is properly diversified across all stock and bond sectors, it’s nearly impossible to benchmark. There are 11 sectors of the stock market and 4 sectors of the bond market, each with underlying asset classes. If you own 100% U.S. large cap stocks, then there’s a case for benchmarking vs. the S&P 500. Otherwise, you can forget about it.
Benchmark Weighting: The NASDAQ is a stock index made up of the largest 100 tech companies. The largest 7 companies now make up FIFTY PERCENT of the index!
The Dow Jones Industrial Average only contains 30 stocks: If you have a solid financial game plan and own a diversified risk-appropriate portfolio, then there shouldn’t be any need to compare to the indexes.
There’s no need to compare!: If you have a solid financial game plan and own a diversified risk-appropriate portfolio, then there shouldn’t be any need to compare to the indexes.
If you’re in need of a financial game plan, or want to know if you’re properly diversified, contact us for a free consultation.